Steve, before I started fishing Eagle I too spent weeks fishing Indian and Canyon. I also found what you did to be true regarding downsizing of baits. After switching to Eagle, obviously the first thing I did was bring my bag of tricks with me and try it out there. Unfortunately, most smaller presentations I have used have been fairly unproductive for Muskies on Eagle. But fortunately, I can honestly say I have seen more big fish in ONE SPOT on Eagle then I have seen combined on Indian/Canyon ever...so while those lakes can be fun to fish and do have their time and place, I think you are making the right choice.