I caught the same small pike 6 times in one evening up at High Point Lake.

I know it was the same fish, because I forgot my hemostats and was fishing with live shiners, so each time I caught the dang thing I ended up leaving a hook in it (I was NOT sticking my fingers in the mouth, it was about a 26" fish so it had nice sized teeth).

So each time I caught it, a new hook was added...by the time I caught him the 6th time, it was time call it quits.

Dang thing looked like a porcupine. The funny thing is he kept going back to the same weed bed, and I moved him the 4th time I caught him 50 yards down shore.