One thing might be is during the 1990's the fishery was hurt pretty bad due to over fishing. Some of us fish it but keep very quiet about it. I personally lost a true 40lber last year boatside fishing by myself on Erie in 4' waves at the end of November. The waves almost got me in trouble on that fish and I almost got pushed up on some big rocks which I am sure would have been horrible. The weather can also be terrible with big waves and wind. Best thing to do is go and try it for yourself. When I fish Erie I look for one bite a day and usually fish big baits. Best luck.