I have a manual bilge pump now and plan on installing a new automatic pump. I saw a recommended wiring diagram which would require that I change the two-way switch (On/Off) on the dash to a new three-way switch (On/Off/Auto). A diagram of the suggested wiring is attached.

Click image for larger version.  Name: Bilge1.jpg  Views: 290  Size: 25.4 KB  ID: 15610


It worries me that if the switch on the dash isn't set to Auto, the pump won't run and my automatic pump won't be automatic. I thought a better way to wire the pump would be in this second diagram (hand drawn).

Click image for larger version.  Name: Bilge2.jpg  Views: 287  Size: 26.4 KB  ID: 15611

This way the pump will run if the boat starts to fill up with water, regardless of whether I forgot to leave the swith in the Auto position.

I'm wondering if I'm missing anything and if anyone has any input to what I think is a better approach. This way I also don't have to find a new three-way switch to fit in my dash where the existing two-way switch is now.

Any comments appreciated.