Ty

We are coming in for vacation from Indiana, staying at Treelands and fishing with you on September 8th. Does this mean we'll be fishing in a new boat?

On the Northwest side of Indy is a 1350 acre lake called Eagle Creek but it is a 10 hp limit lake, so I assume that won't work for what you need. BTW that lake was just stocked with Muskies for the first time this year.

On the Northeast side of Indy is a 1900 acre reservoir called Geist. That might work for you and is probably a little less out of the way than Shaffer or Freeman.

Another option might be Morse due north of Indy.